
Can You Change Medicare Supplement Plans Anytime During the Year?
ANSWER FIRST: Yes. You can apply for a different Medicare Supplement policy any month of the year — you do not have to wait for fall Open Enrollment. The catch is qualifying: outside your Medigap Open Enrollment Period or a guaranteed-issue right, the insurance company can use medical underwriting to accept or decline your application.
One of the biggest Medicare Supplement misconceptions we hear is:
'I'll wait until Medicare Open Enrollment in October to look at changing my Medicare Supplement.'
You may not need to wait.
Medicare Supplement insurance, also called Medigap, doesn't work the same way as Medicare Advantage or Part D prescription drug coverage.
In many situations, you can apply for a different Medicare Supplement policy at any time during the year.
The important question isn't necessarily when you can apply.
It's whether you can qualify.
After your initial Medigap Open Enrollment Period, changing Medicare Supplement companies may require medical underwriting unless you have a guaranteed-issue right or qualify for special protections available in your state.
That's why understanding your options—and reviewing them while you're healthy—can be so important.
You Don't Have to Wait Until AEP to Review Your Medicare Supplement
The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period, commonly called AEP, runs from October 15 through December 7.
That's an important time for people with Medicare Advantage and Part D prescription drug coverage.
But AEP isn't an annual Medicare Supplement enrollment period.
Your federal Medigap Open Enrollment Period is generally a one-time six-month period that begins when you're 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B.
During that initial period, you have important federal protections when purchasing a Medicare Supplement.
Afterward, you may still be able to apply for another Medicare Supplement during the year, but the insurance company may be allowed to ask health questions and use medical underwriting to determine whether it will accept your application.
What About Birthday and Anniversary Rules?
This is where your state can make a difference.
Some states have additional Medicare Supplement protections commonly referred to as birthday rules, anniversary rules, or other special switching rights.
Depending on the state, these rules may provide qualifying Medicare Supplement policyholders an opportunity to change coverage during a specific period with limited or no medical underwriting.
However, these rules aren't the same everywhere.
The length of the enrollment window, which plans you can select, when you can apply, and who qualifies can all vary by state.
That's one reason working with an agent who understands the rules where you live can be valuable.
What Is Medicare Supplement Underwriting?
Underwriting sounds intimidating.
For most consumers, it doesn't need to be.
That's my job.
When underwriting is required, an insurance company may look at things such as your health history, recent diagnoses, treatments, surgeries, hospitalizations and prescription medications.
Different insurance companies can also have different underwriting guidelines.
One company may ask about a particular health condition differently from another.
Carriers can also use different look-back periods for certain conditions or treatments.
This is why I don't recommend randomly submitting applications to multiple companies just because one has a lower rate.
Before recommending an application, I want to understand your health situation and determine which available carrier may be worth considering.
The insurance company always makes the final eligibility decision, but knowing where to look can make a significant difference.
'I Was Declined Before. Doesn't That Mean I'm Stuck?'
Not necessarily.
A previous Medicare Supplement decline doesn't automatically mean every insurance company will decline you today.
Time matters.
Suppose a company's underwriting guidelines ask whether you've received treatment for a particular condition within the previous 24 months.
Something that prevented you from qualifying two years ago may no longer fall within that same look-back period today.
Another carrier may also ask different questions or evaluate your circumstances differently.
That doesn't mean you'll automatically qualify.
It means a previous 'no' shouldn't necessarily become a permanent 'no' without reviewing the situation again.
Why Waiting Until Later Can Matter
Here's a conversation we sometimes have:
'My Medicare Supplement went up, but I'll wait another six months and think about changing.'
You certainly can.
But there's something worth considering:
You know your health situation today. You don't know what it will be six months from now.
If you're healthy enough to qualify for another Medicare Supplement today, waiting doesn't guarantee you'll still meet another company's underwriting requirements later.
A new diagnosis could occur.
A medication could change.
You could have surgery.
You could be hospitalized.
None of us knows what our health will look like several months from now.
That's why, if you're healthy today and your Medicare Supplement premium has become expensive, there may be value in investigating your options now rather than waiting until you feel forced to make a change.
That doesn't mean you should switch.
It means you should know what your options are while you may have options.
'It's Only $40 a Month. Is Changing Really Worth It?'
Let's do the math.
A lower premium of:
- $40 per month = $480 during the first year
- $60 per month = $720 during the first year
- $90 per month = $1,080 during the first year
Now consider that you may keep your Medicare Supplement for many years.
That's why even a seemingly modest monthly difference deserves consideration.
For example, suppose you're currently paying $250 per month for Medicare Supplement Plan G and you're approved for another Plan G at $170 per month.
That's an $80 monthly difference.
Over the first 12 months alone, that's:
$960 in premium savings.
And the potential value of starting at a lower premium isn't necessarily limited to one year.
What Happens When Both Companies Raise Their Rates?
Medicare Supplement premiums can change over time.
Your current company may raise its rates.
The new company may raise its rates too.
We can't predict future rate increases, and we should never assume two companies will increase premiums by exactly the same amount or percentage.
But starting from a substantially lower premium can still matter.
Imagine two hypothetical Plan G premiums:
- Company A: $250 per month
- Company B: $170 per month
If both companies happened to receive similar percentage increases in the future, there could still be a meaningful premium difference because you started from a much lower monthly rate.
Actual future increases may be different, so we can't promise that today's $80 difference will remain $80 forever.
But that's exactly why we look beyond just this month's premium.
We can consider the current rate, available discounts, pricing, the company's rate history when available, and your individual situation before deciding whether a change makes sense.
Aren't All Plan G Policies Basically the Same?
This is another important Medicare Supplement concept.
Medicare Supplement plans are standardized.
If you're comparing Plan G to Plan G, the standardized basic medical benefits are the same regardless of which insurance company sells the policy.
That doesn't mean everything about the insurance companies is identical.
Premiums can differ.
Household discounts can differ.
Customer service can differ.
Pricing methods and rate history can differ.
Underwriting can differ.
But paying a higher premium for Plan G doesn't automatically mean you're receiving more standardized Plan G medical benefits.
That's why the name on the insurance card shouldn't be the only reason you stay with a Medicare Supplement company.
Don't Be Afraid of Underwriting
Some people never compare their Medicare Supplement because they're afraid they'll have to answer health questions.
My advice is simple:
Don't let underwriting scare you. That's my job.
You don't have to learn every insurance company's underwriting guide.
You don't have to figure out every look-back period.
You don't have to decide which company is most likely to consider your health history.
That's what I work through with you.
I'll ask questions about your health and medications and investigate which available options may make sense before we decide whether applying is worthwhile.
Sometimes we'll find an opportunity.
Sometimes we'll determine that waiting makes sense.
And sometimes I'll tell you:
'I think you should stay exactly where you are.'
That's still a successful review.
The purpose isn't to move everyone.
The purpose is to make sure you understand your options.
Never Cancel Your Current Medicare Supplement Too Soon
This is extremely important.
Finding a lower advertised rate isn't the same thing as being approved for a new Medicare Supplement.
If medical underwriting is required, don't cancel your existing Medicare Supplement simply because you've found another policy with a lower premium.
We want to know whether the new insurance company will approve you and understand when the new coverage will become effective before making decisions about your existing policy.
Protect the coverage you already have while we investigate the new option.
When Should You Review Your Medicare Supplement?
There's no requirement that you shop your Medicare Supplement every year.
But I recommend reviewing it periodically—especially when:
- You've received a significant premium increase.
- It's been several years since anyone compared your rate.
- You're currently healthy and wondering whether lower-priced options are available.
- You've previously been declined but enough time may have passed to reconsider underwriting.
- Your premium has become difficult to afford.
- You're wondering whether Plan G, Plan N or another option makes more sense for you.
A review doesn't obligate you to change anything.
Sometimes knowing that your current policy is still a good fit provides just as much value as finding a lower rate.
You Know You're Healthy Today. Why Wait to Find Out Your Options?
If your Medicare Supplement premium has increased, you don't necessarily need to wait until October—or until the next rate increase—to investigate your options.
And if you're healthy today, there can be an advantage to finding out what's available before your health situation changes.
Maybe we find a way to save $40 per month.
Maybe it's $90.
Maybe it's more.
Or maybe we review everything and tell you:
'Stay exactly where you are.'
That's okay too.
The goal isn't to change your Medicare Supplement.
The goal is to make sure you're making an informed decision.
Already have a Medicare Supplement and wondering whether you're paying too much?
Visit MedicareRateRescue.com to request a FREE Medicare Supplement Rate Review.
Or contact:
MedSuppUSA by Central States Insurance
785-342-2684
Let's investigate your options while you have options.
Medicare Supplement availability and underwriting requirements vary by insurance company, state and individual circumstances. Approval is determined by the insurance carrier. Savings examples are illustrative; actual premiums, rate changes and savings vary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change my Medicare Supplement at any time?
You can generally apply for another Medicare Supplement policy during the year. However, outside your initial Medigap Open Enrollment Period, guaranteed-issue situations, or other applicable state protections, the insurance company may be allowed to use medical underwriting and could decline your application.
Do I have to wait until October to change my Medicare Supplement?
Not necessarily. The October 15–December 7 Medicare Annual Enrollment Period primarily applies to Medicare Advantage and Medicare prescription drug coverage. It isn't a general annual Medigap open enrollment period.
Can I change Medicare Supplement companies if I have health problems?
Possibly. It depends on your circumstances, available guaranteed-issue protections, state rules, and—when underwriting is permitted—the insurance company's underwriting requirements.
What if I was declined for a Medicare Supplement before?
A previous decline doesn't necessarily mean you'll receive the same decision today. Health circumstances can change, look-back periods can pass, and underwriting guidelines can differ among carriers. The new insurance company ultimately determines eligibility.
Are all Medicare Supplement Plan G policies the same?
The standardized basic benefits of Plan G are the same regardless of which insurance company sells the policy. Premiums, discounts, underwriting requirements, customer service and other company-specific factors can differ.
Should I change Medicare Supplements just because I find a lower rate?
Not necessarily. Price is important, but it isn't the only consideration. Your eligibility, health, available discounts, carrier information and individual circumstances should all be reviewed before making a decision.
Official Medicare information is available at Medicare.gov and CMS.gov.